Welcome to Door County Creamery
Door County Creamery, located in Sister Bay, WI, is a delightful haven for food lovers. Renowned for its artisanal sandwiches, particularly the Turkey Brie, and its unique offerings like goat ice cream and gourmet cheeses, it offers an exceptional dining experience. Customers rave about the rich flavors crafted from local ingredients and the inviting atmosphere. With options like the famous hot honey sandwich and fresh gelato, every dish is a memorable journey for the palate. Visitors cherish the friendly service and dog-friendly patio, making this quaint creamery a must-visit destination in Door County for food enthusiasts.
-
10653 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234, United States Hotline: +1 920-854-3388
Welcome to Door County Creamery, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of Sister Bay, Wisconsin. Situated at 10653 N Bay Shore Dr, this charming eatery is not just a stop for food; it's a destination for food lovers seeking an unforgettable experience.
Known for its remarkable variety, Door County Creamery specializes in crafting artisanal sandwiches, gourmet cheeses, and uniquely flavored gelato that would make any Italian café envious. Patrons rave about the Turkey Brie sandwich, which is said to be a life-changing choice. It perfectly balances rich flavors and fresh ingredients, leaving you with a satisfying culinary memory you won’t soon forget.
The excitement doesn’t end there. The hot honey sandwich is another standout, praised for its perfectly baked bread, gooey cheese, and a delightful mix of sweet and savory that keeps diners returning for more. Haley Patrick, one enthusiastic reviewer, captured it perfectly: “I will think about it forever.” The combination of flavors creates an experience that lingers long after the meal is finished.
And let’s not overlook the sweet indulgences. The creamy gelato, made fresh daily, has received glowing reviews for its authenticity, reminiscent of gelato found in the streets of Italy. Even those skeptical about trying goat ice cream have found themselves pleasantly surprised, with families declaring it a must-try.
The atmosphere of Door County Creamery is as charming as its offerings. With a cozy patio that is dog-friendly, it is the ideal spot for a leisurely lunch or a quick snack with loved ones. Reviews highlight not only the delicious food but also the friendly and attentive service, ensuring a welcoming experience for all visitors. Customers have noted the willingness of staff to accommodate special requests, showing a dedication to making every visit special.
In addition to the mouthwatering sandwiches and exquisite gelato, you'll find a selection of gourmet cheeses, spreads, and snacks, making it a perfect stop for gift shopping. Whether you're in the mood for a substantial meal or just a quick treat, Door County Creamery caters to every craving.
As Audra Van Lanen said, “Do not skip a stop here!” if you’re in Door County. The blend of quality ingredients, creative dishes, and inviting vibes create a must-visit culinary experience. If you're seeking a taste of something truly unique, make your way to Door County Creamery—your taste buds will thank you.
For inquiries, feel free to contact them at +1 920-854-3388.
Do not skip a stop here! Best lunch spot in the area. The Turkey Brie will change your life! Gelato is made fresh, reminds of Italy. Such a cute vibe and I will be back again!
This place is insanely good. It is a little pricey but you really get what you pay for. I think I’m truly going to dream about the turkey and Brie. Will definitely be going back next time we visit door county!
The hot honey sandwich is THE perfect sandwich. The bread is crunchy and soft, the cheese is gooey and all over. It has a touch of heat with sweet and salty mixed in. I will think about it forever. Highly recommend! Turkey and Brie was also great if you want something a little more lowkey. Very nice patio that is dog friendly as well.
Honestly. The hot Sammy was the best sandwich I’ve had in my entire life. Warm meats with perfectly baked bread. I was shocked how good the food was. A bit pricier but you absolutely get what you pay for. Outstanding..
I was hesitant at first to go in because I’ve never had Goat Ice Cream before. To my surprise the place had more than just goat ice cream, they had goat cheese, spread, goat feta cheese, coffee, pastry and snacks. And lots of cute gifts too. So the verdict from my children is: goat ice cream is amazing!! And goat feta cheese is where it is! Must try!
Delicious sandwich, soup and cookie! The turkey and Brie is magnificent! I could only eat half because it was so big, but excited to finish it late. The tomato basil soup was fabulous and the cookie was the best way to finish! The staff was so friendly and the cooks are polite and handsome.
I've been here a few times and each time has been a great experience. The products are delicious from sandwiches, cheese, ice cream, and anything else edible. On this trip, I had a special request and the team, especially Allie & Lola (I apologize if I don't have the correct spelling) helped make it work. This creamery is the ONLY place I get ice cream... Thank you! - Hazelnut Pines ;)
The breakfast BLT, coffee, and chocolate chip cookies were all delicious! A little on the pricey side, but the fantastic service more than made up for it. Definitely worth a visit!